Turkish Journal of Pathology

Türk Patoloji Dergisi

Turkish Journal of Pathology

Turkish Journal of Pathology

2010, Vol 26, Num, 2     (Pages: 147-152)

Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology of Pediatric Thyroid Nodules

Ayper KAÇAR 1, İrem PAKER 2, Gülşah KABAÇAM BAYRAM 3, Fatma DEMİREL 4, Emrah ŞENEL 5, Murat KIZILGÜN 6

1 Departments of Pathology, M.H. Dışkapı Pediatric Education and Research Hospital, ANKARA, TURKEY
2 Departments of Pathology, M.H. Dışkapı Yıldırım Beyazıt Education and Research Hospital, ANKARA, TURKEY
3 Departments of Radiology, M.H. Dışkapı Paediatric Education and Research Hospital, ANKARA, TURKEY
4 Departments of Endocrine, M.H. Dışkapı Paediatric Education and Research Hospital, ANKARA, TURKEY
5 Departments of Pediatric Surgery, M.H. Dışkapı Paediatric Education and Research Hospital, ANKARA, TURKEY
6 Departments of Biochemistry, M.H. Dışkapı Paediatric Education and Research Hospital, ANKARA, TURKEY

DOI: 10.5146/tjpath.2010.01012
Viewed: 7089
Downloaded : 1906


Objective: The objectives were to evaluate fine needle aspiration cytology results of 39 pediatric patients, and the pathologies that cause childhood thyroid nodules, and to review the literature on the subject.

Material and Method: Thyroid fine needle aspiration cytology results of 39 pediatric patients were retrospectively reviewed. Associated diseases, thyroid functions, anti-thyroid antibody levels, ultrasonographic findings and number of nodules were also evaluated.

Results: The vast majority of patients with thyroid nodules were cytopathologically diagnosed as benign (97.3%). Of these patients, 64.8% (24 patients) were diagnosed as nodular goiter and 35.2% (13 patients) as lymphocytic thyroiditis. Thyroid malignancy was found in two patients; one was diagnosed as follicular neoplasm/ minimal invasive follicular carcinoma on surgical evaluation while the other was a secondary tumor (Burkitt's lymphoma). The majority of our subjects were females (66.6%): the female/male ratio was 2:1 for nodular goiter and 3.3:1 for thyroiditis. Surgical resection was performed in 5 patients (4 cases of nodular goiter, 1 suspicious for malignancy) and cytological diagnoses were confirmed by histology.

Conclusion: Our study confirmed the utility of fine needle aspiration cytology in childhood thyroid disorders along with a possible higher incidence of nodular thyroiditis in childhood. Nodular autoimmune thyroiditis, focal thyroiditis and thyroid cancer in children are discussed and attention is drawn to some special subtypes of thyroid cancer and some benign lesions that can cause difficulty in interpreting fine needle aspiration cytology and frozen sections at this age.


The incidence of thyroid nodules in children by clinical examination is estimated at 1-1.5%. The incidence of a thyroid nodules in the general population is 19-35%. Malignancy develops in less than 5% of these[1] while this rate can go up to 25% in childhood thyroid nodules[1-5]. There are also reports of a low incidence (2%) of malignancy development in nodules in this age[6].

Childhood thyroid nodules may develop due to nodular hyperplasia, thyroiditis (Hashimoto and Graves), malignancy, congenital hypothyroidism (dyshormonogenetic goiter), thyroid hemiagenesis and thyroglossal ductus cyst. Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) has been reported to provide sensitivity, specificity and possible use of cytological criteria in children that are similar to adults[1,7]. There are only a few pediatric series of thyroid nodules and their reported thyroiditis and malignancy rates vary with reported thyroiditis rates of 2 to 48% and malignancy rates of 2 to 50%[1,3,4,6-15]. There are also few studies on the thyroiditis-thyroid cancer association in childhood. A series of 365 autoimmune thyroiditis (AIT) cases in children reported a nodule in 115 (31%) of which 11 (3%) were malignant[4]. There are again very few reports on some thyroid carcinoma types[16,17,18] and entities[19] that seem to be specific to childhood.

The aim of this study was to investigate the results of FNAC in childhood pediatric thyroid nodules, evaluate the association between thyroid pathologies and thyroid cancer, observe some demographic characteristics of childhood thyroid pathologies and to increase the sensitivity of a multidisciplinary approach to these cases. We also correlated the hormonal status, thyroid antibody level and ultrasonography (USG) results of these cases with their FNAC results. Another aim of this study was to review the literature data on the clinicopathological analysis of pediatric thyroid nodules.


The study was retrospective in nature. A total of 50 thyroid fine needle aspiration (FNA) material from 47 cases were found between 2005 and 2009 in the Pathology Clinic archives. The classical four-way classification system was used for cytopathological diagnoses. The cases were divided into benign, malignant, suspicious and nondiagnostic categories. 8 nondiagnostic cases were excluded from the study. 42 thyroid FNA material of 39 cases were evaluated once again by 2 pathologists and the cytopathological findings and diagnosis distribution were evaluated. A table was also made of the gender, age, concurrent disease, presentation symptom, hormonal status, antibody levels and USG results of the cases. FNA was performed by a radiologist under USG, using a 21 gauge needle. There were no complications during the procedure. Part of the smear was air-dried and stained with May-Grünwald-Giemsa while the other part was fixed with 95% alcohol and stained with PAP in all cases. Sections were obtained from the surgical specimens after paraffinization and H&E applied.


The age range was 4-18 years with a mean age of 11±1. Our series had 26 females (66.6%) and 13 males (33.3%) (F: M=2:1). Nodular goiter (NG) was diagnosed in 24 patients with 16 females and 8 males (F:M=2:1). There were 13 chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis (CLT) patients with 10 females and 3 males (F:M=3.3:1).

All cases except two presented with a neck swelling. One of the two cases was a nodular goiter case diagnosed with a high TSH level while being followed-up for Hodgkin's lymphoma. The other case had thyroiditis and had presented with shortness of stature and developmental retardation.

Laboratory results:
Thyroid function test results of 13 NG cases were available and 10 were euthyroid, 3 hypothyroid. Of the thyroiditis cases, 4 were euthyroid and 2 hypothyroid.

Antithyroid antibody levels of 11 NG cases were known and only 1 had high antithyroid peroxidase (anti TPO) levels. This was a multinodular goiter case who also suffered from the McCune-Albright syndrome and the results of both FNA procedures performed with a 2-year interval were consistent with NG. Antithyroid antibody levels were known in 6 thyroiditis cases and 4 had high antibody titers while 2 were negative.

USG findings:
There was a single thyroid nodule or multiple nodules in all cases except the three thyroiditis cases. There was a single nodule in 8 and multiple nodules in 16 of the 24 NG cases on USG. The nodules were hypoechogenic and heterogenous in 11 cases, isoechogenic and heterogenous in 3 cases and hypoechogenic and homogenous in 5 cases. Parenchyma was heterogenous in only 3 cases.

No nodule was found on USG in the thyroid parenchyma of 3 of the 13 CLT cases; the gland was generally heterogenous and hypoechogenic. There was a single hypoechogenic and/or heterogenous nodule in 6 cases and multiple heterogenous and hypoechogenic nodules in 4 cases. The gland parenchyma was homogenous in 4 of these cases and heterogenous in 1 case.

Another pathology (1 McCune-Albright Syndrome, 1 Hodgkin's lymphoma) accompanied only 2 NG cases out of the 39 cases in total.

Cytopathological findings:
Of the 42 FNA cases, 40 were evaluated as benign (27 NG, 13 CLT), 1 suspicious for malignancy and 1 malignant (Burkitt's lymphoma).

Cytopathological analysis of NG cases showed a colloid background with groups of thyrocytes that were mostly arranged in sheets but consisted micro- or macrofollicular structures in some parts and, in some cases, foamy histiocytes and stromal fragments.

Cytologic preparations of thyroiditis cases were generally poor in thyrocytes and contained little colloid. The polymorphic lymphoid infiltrate was striking in these cases (Figure 1).

Figure 1: Lymphoid cells at various stages of maturation (MGG, x100).

The case where malignancy was suspected was 7 years old and had presented with a neck mass and hypothyroidism. USG showed a homogenous, isoechogenic, solid nodule in the right thyroid lodge that was cold on scintigraphy with a size of 3.5x3.2 cm and a partial peripheral halo. The rest of the parenchyma was homogenous. Aspiration cytology showed thyrocytes that had a metaplastic appearance with eccentric nuclei in places, containing pseudoinclusion-like structures with a high nucleus/cytoplasm ratio that were distributed as microfollicular and papillary structures in a colloid-poor background and foamy macrophages with nuclei showing atypical endocrine appearance (Figure 2A, B). The case was thought to be suspicious for malignancy with these cytological findings but no differentiation was made between a follicular neoplasm and papillary neoplasm. Histopathological examination revealed a solid nodule with scattered calcification areas consisting of thyroid follicules of various sizes that contained papillary structures in part. The nuclei were large and vesicular but there were no diagnostic findings of papillary carcinoma (PC). There was an extracapsular area of suspicious vascular invasion that stained positive immunohistochemically with mesothelin. The capsule invasion could not be clearly demonstrated and the case was therefore accepted as follicular neoplasm (minimal invasive carcinoma?). The case has been followedup for 3 years without recurrence.

Figure 2A: Hypercellularity, papillary and microfollicular structures (H&E, x100).

Figure 2B: A crowded 3-dimensional papillary structure consisting of cells with a high N/C ratio (MGG, x200).

There were synchronous thyroid and intraabdominal masses in the case diagnosed as malignant. FNA evaluation of the thyroid showed an atypical cell population consisting of cells of moderate size with a monotonous appearance and round nuclear borders with microvacuoles in their narrow basophilic cytoplasms (Figure 3). The case was reported as consistent with lymphoma (primarily Burkitt). The histopathological and immunohistochemical evaluation results of the tru-cut biopsy material from the intraabdominal mass also supported the diagnosis of Burkitt's lymphoma.

Figure 3: Tumor cells of moderate size with monotonous appearance and round shape, containing paranuclear microvacuoles (MGG, x1000 imm. oil).

Four of the 5 cases that underwent surgical resection had NG and one had findings suspicious for malignancy on cytopathology. The histopathological results were found to be consistent with the FNA results in all cases.


FNA is a relatively simple procedure with a low complication rate. This procedure has become a routine part of thyroid nodule investigation in adults but is still not in common use in childhood thyroid nodules. Excellent results have been reported for thyroid FNA procedures. Some reports have emphasized a marked superiority to USG and scintigraphy in differentiating malignant and benign lesions[1]. High sensitivity and specificity rates are also reported when compared with cases where only antibody titers are evaluated for AIT diagnosis[12,14,20,21]. The sensitivity and specificity further increases when used together with serology, USG and FNA. The success of FNA procedure is directly influenced by the performing person's experience (adequate and correct sample that represents the lesion) and the competence of the pathologist interpreting the findings. Both these factors determine the false-positive and true-negative rates.

Analysis of thyroid pathology series in childhood shows that females make up the majority of cases (75-90%)[1,4,9] and that the mean age generally corresponds to childhood and adolescence (12.5-17 years)[1,7,9,16,21,22]. Some reports have a higher incidence of male patients when malignancy is present[4,22]. Females made up 66.6% of the cases in our series and the mean age was 11+/-1. NG (61.5%) and CLT (33.3%) made up the majority of the thyroid nodules in our study. A thyroid malignancy was found in 2 of the 39 cases included in the study (5.2%). Surgical procedure was used in a total of 5 cases (1 malignant in 4NG). The histopathology results were consistent with FNA results in all these cases.

Evaluation of the rates of benign cases and CLT in adult series of FNA in the literature has shown a rate of 62-64% for benigncases[23,24] while thyroiditis rate is 1-11%[23,25]. The rate of thyroiditis in childhood thyroid nodules in our series (33%) was significantly higher than adult series. This result needs to be supported with larger series in this age group.

Thyroid carcinomas are rare solid tumors of childhood. Pediatric thyroid nodules are reported to be less frequent than adult nodules but to contain malignancy more often while pediatric well-differentiated thyroid carcinomas show earlier spread to the surrounding tissues and lymph nodes compared to adult forms and distant metastases and recurrences are more common[1-5]. Despite all these unfavorable elements, pediatric thyroid carcinomas generally have a much better prognosis than their adult counterparts with an almost 100% disease-free survival[4,22,26]. The association of the prognosis with age is frequently emphasized[27,28]. PC constitutes the majority of childhood thyroid carcinomas (60%, 68%, 91%, 93%)[16,18,22,29]. Other common types are, in order of frequency, follicular carcinoma, medullary carcinoma and Hürthle cell carcinoma. Thyroid PC has been reported to possibly have a special form in children younger than 10 years that consists of a combination of follicular and solid areas with nuclear pseudoinclusions and nuclear border irregularities but without classical PC findings such as nuclear notching that usually shows widespread psammoma bodies and infiltration within the whole gland[16].

Although the incidence of malignancy in our series falls within the range reported in the literature, it may be better to increase the number of cases in the series. We believe that the rates varying between 2 and 50% in the literature are partly due to the way the series are formed and depend on whether they are from an oncology reference hospital or not.

AIT is the most common cause of goiter in the pediatric age group after iodine deficiency. The most common causes are Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) and Graves' disease. HT is more common in childhood and the atrophic form is rare. The diagnosis is made with antibody titers and/or FNA[12]. There are varied reports of the prevalence of a nodule in pediatric AIT cases. Some publications report all AIT cases as diffuse goiter[12] while others report various incidences of nodule development (3.3%, 31%, 27.8%, 28%)[4,21,30,31]. Most (77%) of the CLT cases diagnosed via FNA in our clinic had a single nodule or multiple nodules. None of the cases were malignant. The lack of series in the pediatric age group in the literature has led to very few nodular AIT cases studied in childhood[3,4]. A report with 365 pediatric AIT cases has found a nodule incidence of 31% with a cancer incidence of 9.6% (all PC) in these nodules[4]. Although the cytomorphological findings overlap between children and adults for CLT, possibly less prominent fibrosis and germinal centers and Hürthle cell changes in children must be taken into account[20]. The smear results of thyroiditis cases in our study supported these findings. The smears generally contained few thyrocytes with a dense lymphoid infiltrate and little colloid.

In conclusion, FNAC is an effective method for the differential diagnosis of thyroid pathologies and thyroid nodules but we would like to emphasize some characteristics of this age group:

1) There are reports of focal thyroiditis accompanying pediatric PC[5,32,33]. Pediatric nodular lymphocytic thyroditis cases that are FNAB (+) but have repeated negative autoantibody levels need close monitoring and surgery may be required to exclude a neoplasm[25]. Cases of nodular thyroiditis with inadequate content require repeat biopsy.

2) Childhood thyroid carcinomas can differ from adult forms; the PC subtypes of this age are childhood papillary carcinoma[16] and diffuse sclerosing PC that may blend in with a clinical picture of serology (+) thyroiditis[17,18].

3) The FNAB and frozen procedures from the nodules that develop on a base of dyshormonogenetic goiter and the pediatric solitary papillary hyperplastic thyroid nodules (hot nodule with autonomous function) can lead to diagnostic difficulties and misinterpretations. These cases can be differentiated from PC with the clinical history, and FNAC findings of cytoplasmic marginal vacuoles, non-branching short papillae, the lack of nuclear pseudoinclusions and the presence of a large colloid content[18,19].


1) Hosler GA, Clark I, Zakowsky MF, Westra WH, Ali SZ: Cytopathologic analysis of thyroid lesions in the pediatric population. Diagn Cytopathol 2006, 34: 101-105 [ Özet ]

2) Josefson J, Zimmerman D: Thyroid nodules and cancers in children. Pediatr Endocrinol Rev 2008, 6:14-23 [ Özet ]

3) Mann B, Riede E, Runkel N, Buhr HJ: Benign thyroid gland diseases in childhood and adolescence-early indications for surgical therapy. Langenbecks Arch Chir Suppl Kongressbd 1998, 115:1044-1047 [ Özet ]

4) Corrias A, Cassio A, Weber G, Mussa A, Wasniewska M, Rapa A, Gastaldi R, Einaudi S, Baronio F, Vigone MC, Messina MF, Bal M, Bona G, de Sanctis C: Thyroid nodules and cancer in children and adolescents affected by autoimmune thyroiditis. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2008, 162: 526-531 [ Özet ]

5) Pascanu I, Borda A, Banescu C: Thyroid nodule with Hashimoto thyroiditis in childhood- a challenging experience. Rom J Morphol Embryol 2008, 49:541-545 [ Özet ]

6) Rallison ML, Dobyns BM, Keating FR Jr, Rall JE, Tyler FH: Thyroid nodularity in children. JAMA 1975, 233:1069-1072 [ Özet ]

7) Amrikachi M, Ponder TB, Wheeler TM, Smith D, Ramzy I: Thyroid fine-needle aspiration biopsy in children and adolescents: Experience with 218 aspirates. Diagn Cytopathol 2005, 32:189- 192 [ Özet ]

8) Bachrach LK, Foley TP Jr: Thyroiditis in children. Pediatr Rev 1989, 11:184-191 [ Özet ]

9) Chang SH, Joo M, Kim H: Fine needle aspiration biopsy of thyroid nodules in children and adolescents. J Korean Med Sci 2006, 21:469-473 [ Özet ]

10) Sakkurada N: Evaluation of cytological examination by aspiration biopsy for the diagnosis of chronic thyroiditis in childhood. Bull Tokyo Med Dent Univ 1979, 26:279-286 [ Özet ]

11) Al-Shaikh A, Ngan B, Daneman A, Daneman D: Fine needle aspiration biopsy in the management of thyroid nodules in children and adolescents. J Pediatr 2001, 138:140-142 [ Özet ]

12) Gopalakrishnan S, Kumar Chugh P, Chillar M, Ambardar VK, Sahoo M, Sankar R: Goitrous autoimmune thyroiditis in a pediatric population: A longitudinal study. Pediatrics 2008, 122:670-674

13) Stevens C, Al-Mahmeed H, Blair G, Prasil P, Haider F, Sweeney B, Cowan K, Butter A, deBuys Roessingh A, Bouchard S, Weinsheimer R, Yanchar N, Jones S, Alfadhli W, Fitzgerald P, Ryckman J, Puligandla P: The Canadian pediatric thyroid nodule study: an evaluation of current management practices. J Pediatr Surg 2008, 43:826-830 [ Özet ]

14) Corrias A, Einaudi S, Chiorboli E, Weber G, Crinò A, Andreo M, Cesaretti G, de Sanctis L, Messina MF, Segni M, Cicchetti M, Vigone M, Pasquino AM, Spera S, de Luca F, Mussa GC, Bona G: Accuracy of fine needle aspiration biopsy of thyroid nodules in detecting malignancy in childhood: Comparison with conventional clinical, laboratory and imaging approaches. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2001, 86:4644-4648 [ Özet ]

15) Karagüzel G, Tanyel FC, Büyükpamukçu N, Hiçsönmez A: Is there any predictive charactheristics for malignancy in thyroid enlargements during childhood. Eur J Pediatr Surg 1996, 6:70-74 [ Özet ]

16) Harach HR, Williams ED: Childhood thyroid cancer in England and Wales. Br J Cancer 1995, 72:777 [ Özet ]

17) Wu PS, Leslie PJ, McLaren KM, Toft AD: Diffuse sclerosing papillary carcinoma of thyroid: a wolf in sheep's clothing. Clin Endocrinol 1989, 31: 535-540 [ Özet ]

18) Nishiyama RH: Overview of surgical pathology of the thyroid gland. World J Surg 2000, 24:898-906 [ Özet ]

19) Khurana KK, Baloch ZW, LiVolsi VA: Aspiration cytology of pediatric solitary papillary hyperplastic thyroid nodule. Arch Pathol Lab Med 2001, 125:1575-1578 [ Özet ]

20) Gopalakrishnan S, Marwaha K: Juvenile autoimmune thyroiditis. Journal of Pediatric Endocrinology and Metabolism 2007, 20:961- 970 [ Özet ]

21) Marwaha RK, Sankar R, Magdum M, Nijahvan VS, Khanna CM, Jaggi CB, Ambardar V, Maharda NS, Valia RP, Jain SK: Clinical, biochemical and cytomorphological observations in juvenile chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis. Indian Pediatrics 1998, 35:967-973 [ Özet ]

22) Collini P, Massimino M, Leite SF, Mattavelli F, Seregni E, Zucchini N, Spreafico F, Ferrari A, Castellani MR, Cantù G, Fossati-Bellani F, Rosai J: Papillary thyroid carcinoma of childhood and adolescence: a 30-year experience at the Istituto Nazionali Tumori in Milan. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2006, 46:300- 306 [ Özet ]

23) Sangalli G, Serio G, Zampatti C, Bellotti M, Lomuscio G: Fine needle aspiration cytology of the thyroid: a comparison of 5469 cytological and final histological diagnoses. Cytopathology 2006, 17:245-250 [ Özet ]

24) Yang J, Schnadig V, Logrono R, Wasserman PG: Fine needle aspiration of thyroid nodules: a study of 4703 patients with histologic and clinical correlations. Cancer 2007, 111:306-315 [ Özet ]

25) Tseleni-Balafouta S, Kyroudi-Voulgari A, Paizi-Biza P, Papacharalampous NX: Lymphocytic thyroiditis in fine-needle aspirates: differential diagnostic aspects. Diagn Cytopathol 1989, 5:362-365 [ Özet ]

26) Grigsby PW, Gal-or A, Michalski JM, Doherty GM: Childhood and adolescent thyroid carcinoma. Cancer 2002, 95:724-729 [ Özet ]

27) Alessandri AJ, Goddard KJ, Blair GK, Fryer CJ, Schultz KR: Age is the major determinant of recurrence in pediatric differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Med Pediatr Oncol 2000, 35:41-46 [ Özet ]

28) Lazar L, Lebenthal Y, Steinmetz A, Yackobovitch-Gavan M, Phillip M: Differentiated thyroid carcinoma in pediatric patients: comparison of presentation and course between pre-pubertal children and adolescents. J Pediatr 2009, 154:708-714 [ Özet ]

29) Arici C, Erdogan O, Altunbas H, Boz A, Melikoglu M, Karayalcin B, Karpuzoglu T: Differentiated thyroid carcinoma in children and adolescents. Clinical characteristics, treatment and outcome of 15 patients. Horm Res 2002, 57:153-156 [ Özet ]

30) Yeşilkaya E, Belen B, Bideci A, Çamurdan O, Boyraz M, Cinaz P: Kronik otoimmün tiroiditli çocuk ve ergenlerin klinik özellikleri. Gülhane Tıp Dergisi 2008, 50:147-150

31) Szymborska M, Staroszczyk B: Thyroiditis in children. Personal observations. Med Wieku Rozwoj 2000, 4:383-391 [ Özet ]

32) Modi J, Patel A, Terrel R, Tuttle RM, Francis GL: Papillary thyroid carcinomas from young adults and children contain a mixture of lymphocytes. J. Clin Endocrinol Metab 2003, 88:4418- 4425 [ Özet ]

33) Van Savell H Jr, Hughes SM, Bower C, Parham DM: Lymphocytic Lymphocytic infiltration in pediatric thyroid carcinomas. Pediatric and Developmental Pathology 2004, 7:487-492 [ Özet ]

Keywords : Pediatric thyroid nodules, Thyroid nodules, Cytology, Fine needle aspiration cytology